The Ohio State Buckeyes are at a crossroads, and it’s a moment that could define their future. Five star players have declared for the 2026 NFL Draft, leaving fans and analysts alike wondering: What does this mean for the team’s upcoming season? But here’s the silver lining—seven draft-eligible starters are expected to return, signaling a potential powerhouse lineup for the Buckeyes. Let’s dive into the details and explore the decisions that could shape Ohio State’s trajectory.
The Departures: A Mix of Expected and Strategic Moves
There were no jaw-dropping surprises when Caleb Downs, Arvell Reese, Carnell Tate, Kayden McDonald, and Max Klare announced their early entries into the NFL Draft. These players were widely projected as first-round picks, making their decisions almost inevitable. Downs, Reese, and Tate, in particular, are considered locks for the top 10, with Tate potentially joining them. McDonald, fresh off a unanimous All-American season, is expected to land in the latter half of the first round. Even Klare, who might have benefited from another year at Ohio State, decided to take the leap after transferring for just one season.
But here’s where it gets controversial: Was Klare’s decision premature? As a likely third-round pick, he could have boosted his stock with another year of development. Yet, his choice raises questions about the balance between college growth and NFL readiness. What do you think—did Klare make the right call, or should he have stayed?
The Returners: A Core of Experience and Potential
Ohio State has successfully retained a core group of starters, including wide receiver Brandon Inniss, offensive linemen Austin Siereveld, Luke Montgomery, and Carson Hinzman, and defensive end Kenyatta Jackson Jr. These players have chosen to return for another year, a decision that could pay dividends for both their development and the team’s success. Siereveld and Montgomery, with only one full season as starters, have ample room to grow, while Hinzman aims to elevate his late-round projection with a strong final season.
And this is the part most people miss: Kenyatta Jackson Jr. was seen as a potential early departure, especially after a season that fell short of first-round expectations. By staying, he’s not just betting on himself—he’s positioning himself as the leader of the defensive line. Could this be the move that propels him into the early rounds next year?
The Uncertain: Two Key Players Yet to Decide
Cornerback Jermaine Mathews Jr. and right tackle Phillip Daniels have not publicly announced their plans, but the expectation is that they’ll return. Mathews, a potential middle-round pick, has significant room for improvement after just one year as a full-time starter. Daniels, with two years of eligibility remaining, was never a likely draft entrant, but his decision to stay would solidify the offensive line.
The Outgoing Seniors: A Legacy in the Making
Eleven players, including linebacker Sonny Styles, defensive end Caden Curry, and cornerback Davison Igbinosun, have exhausted their eligibility and are NFL-bound. Styles, a projected first-round pick, could help Ohio State tie its record of five first-round selections in a single draft—a feat achieved in 2006 and 2016. Curry and Igbinosun are likely mid-round picks, while others like Lorenzo Styles Jr. and CJ Donaldson will seek opportunities as undrafted free agents.
Here’s a thought-provoking question: With so much talent leaving, can Ohio State maintain its dominance in the Big Ten? Or will the returning starters step up to fill the void?
Final Thoughts
Ohio State’s draft decisions reflect a blend of individual ambition and team strategy. While losing five stars is a significant blow, retaining seven draft-eligible starters could set the stage for another strong season. As the Buckeyes navigate this transition, one thing is clear: the future is both uncertain and full of potential. What’s your take? Are the Buckeyes poised for success, or will the departures leave a gap too large to fill? Let us know in the comments!
